Bring on the Euro!

Back in the day before it's inception in January 2002, I remember saying that I was against Britain joining the Eurozone. Back then a mixture of youthful inexperience and British pride made that decision for me. Looking back in light of the knowledge I have acquired since, I still agree with the decision made back then. Sterling was a pillar of strength for the country and essential to maintain the strength of the FS industry in the City. Also, the nature of the housing market in the UK meant that more people are exposed to variable rate debt which could have been susceptible to unfavourable interest rate changes by the ECB. Since 2002, the government, media and the public have employed traditional hostility towards adopting the common currency.

As Paul Taylor in the Telegraph put it, "For most of the past decade, as the flexible, finance-driven British economy was roaring ahead of its sluggish Continental cousins, the economic and political case for joining the single European currency was hard to make."

The picture changed on Monday when the president of the EU commission, Jose Manuel Barroso, said Britain is "closer than ever before" to joining the euro. There is obviously an element of political spin from Mr.Barroso - the UK, being the fifth largest economy in the world, would be a boost to the standing of the EU. However, he has spotted an opportunity to take advantage of a drop in confidence in the country due to the financial crisis which may make even the staunchest cynic of the euro reconsider the option.

We are entering an era where he pressures on the pound are mounting. Next year, total government borrowing will be a whopping 8% of GDP and total government debt by 2014 will reach 57.4% of GDP. The housing market is collapsing and the pound has fallen 21% against a basket of currencies in 15 months. It is very likely that the Bank of England will drop interest rates to unprecedented new lows and they are likely to stay low for the foreseeable future. The result - downwards pressure on the pound, higher import costs, higher prices, lower consumer spending, higher unemployment...hardly what we need right now(see my last blog entry).

The mantra expelled by the commission is that "the euro protects." In my opinion, that is exactly what this country needs right now - protection from an over exuberant government, more interested in scoring political points than the future welfare of the public. The government would be obliged to follow the rules set out by the ECB for sound financial and economic prudence. In fact, if the UK were a member of the euro, the commission would already have initiated an "excessive deficit procedure," demanding that the UK gets its borrowing under control. In effect, it gives the government some accountability to a higher body.

Some would argue that this is a disadvantage since the government would not be able to employ monetary tools to safeguard the UK's economy. Interest rate decisions made by the ECB would be made for the benefit of the eurozone as a whole and may not be to the benefit of the UK's economy, for example if a majority of the eurozone is in a recession and the UK is not. Essentially, the UK would be at the mercy of the euros performance in those countries within the zone. A bad thing when the UK's economy was healthy, but remember that forecasts are that the UK will be hardest hit economy during the global recession. Through joining the euro, we may be able to seek strength from the more prosperous European countries (I am mainly thinking of Germany here).

There are also benefits for business and employment. A single and transparent currency will tempt more UK businesses to compete in mainland Europe and, visa versa, will encourage European businesses to venture into the UK - both boosting job creation. A prosperous combined Europe could think of challenging the USA in new and existing markets. A weak pound means higher prices for imports, a stable euro will encourage imports.

The idea of joining the euro will be seen by most people as an extreme one. The government have responded to Mr.Barroso's comments by reaffirming their position against it. And I am not stupid enough to believe that public opinion will change enough overnight to force the government into reassessing their position. However, I do think that the impending problems facing our economy and currency should force at least a rethink in near future. The government at least have a duty to explore whether the pound is a sustainable currency. Unfortunately, in reality the situation is going to have to become much worse before we see anything significant happening.


FTSE....

The FTSE has been swinging in roundabouts since my last post on the 21st Nov. Some of the big levels I mentioned before have come into play (support @ 3700, 3830, 3945 and 4075).

Last week the FTSE bounced back above 4200 following news of the Citi bailout and fiscal stimulus plans in Europe with the EU Commission set to formally unveil a plan aimed at stimulating the economy, amongst other news. Some commentators have gone so far as to say that the deleveraging process which has largely contributed to the fall in the FTSE is coming to an end which may stimulate the markets. Again, in the short term, this is nothing but a temporary bull in an otherwise bear market, confirmed when the markets opened on Monday.

This week has seen the FTSE fall below 4000 again due to further recessionary concerns and the release of some terrible economic figures. Since then the FTSE has fluctuated violently in a tunnel between 3950 and 4170. Short term support @ 4035 and resistance @ 4165.

There are no outstandingly obvious entry points at the moment - in a week that one of Britain's oldest retailers Woolworths faced administration, the FTSE rallied. It seems that market sentiment is not reacting rationally which makes it so hard to read. I think the FTSE will end the year below 4000 - 4165 provides an entry point.