Big drop in Inflation - good or bad news?!

Every couple of days it seems there is an economic release which triggers a change of sentiment. As a consequence of the drop in the base rate and a fall in commodity prices, inflation has fallen from 5.2% in September to 4.5% in October - the biggest drop in 16 yrs! Despite the drop, the rate is still well above the BoE's 2% target.

So is this good or bad news?

A few months ago, inflation was the main concern for the Monetary Policy Committee (MPC). Inflation was above the 2% target and the pressure was on the MPC to curb the rise in prices. The problem was that the economic outlook was also bleak so there were two separate forces pulling the committee. Preceding the minutes of the MPC's interest rate decision meeting published today, Tim Besley (a member of the committee) cited that "the outlook for inflation had changed dramatically between August and the rate cut in early November. "

The rate cut was a tool to encourage consumer spending and to lower the cost of borrowing. The effect of this (if it works) is inflation. But the problem is that people are not spending money - despite the rate cut people would rather save because there is no short term confidence. Add that to falling commodity prices and we have a new buzz word - deflation.

Deflation in the short term is a not necessarily a bad thing - prices fall which encourages people to spend. The knock on effect into the medium term however, is dangerous. In prolonged periods of deflation, consumers hold off buying goods, reckoning they will be cheaper later. This can lead to further falls in demand and output. As firms sell less, they respond by cutting jobs or cutting wages. Overall, consumers then have less money to spend - and demand falls yet again. And the spiral continues....

What this means is that we can expect further cuts from the BoE in the next few months as they try to avoid deflationary pressures. Good news for borrowers, terrible news for savers.

The key point I would like to note is how the BoE's sentiment has changed so quickly. One second inflation is the worry, they react (quite late I must add...a criticism which has been frequently aimed towards the MPC) and now deflation is the worry. It strikes me that the mandate which gives the BoE monetary control over inflation is nothing but a political tool.

Controlling inflation through interest rates is virtually impossible in the UK because we are so reliant on imports. The UK runs on a current account deficit - we import more than we export - and the cost of imports is determined by the cost of inputs (raw materials, labour etc) in the exporting country and the relative strength of the importing currency. The pound is weakening so the cost of importing has gone up so we should be seeing inflation. However, the the cost of raw materials is decreasing, which suggests deflation. So the overall effect is determined by these offsetting factors.

We are seeing falling inflation due to the culmination of decreased consumer spending caused by the bleak economic outlook which suggests that the fall in the price of raw materials is greater than the pound has devalued (arguable point). What I predict will happen is that we will see the fall in inflation overshoot into deflation for one simple reason - the MPC are reactionary. They act to and not in anticipation of the future economic climate. Some may even argue that their goal of controlling inflation is redundant since there are so many externalities involved that their weapon of choice namely interest rates, is not influential enough to make a difference.

I can see the reasoning behind both schools of thought. My opinion is that, regardless of which one you agree with, expecting the MPC to control inflation is an absolute joke!

FTSE......

And another great call if I do say so myself!

FTSE hit 4075 mark early on Tuesday morning before retracing back to 4200 mark. Was trading in that channel for a while until falling heavily today. As I write this, it has fallen below the 4075 mark with next support at 3945. I expect a retrace back to 4075 where another shorting opportunity may arise.